
I’ve written before about how, when I finished The Professor of Eventide, and for the first time since I wrote Her Dear & Loving Husband, I didn’t know what my next writing project would be. I still don’t. I have a few ideas I’m kicking around, but nothing has risen to the top yet.
For more than two decades, writing was the center of my creative life. It was the thing I returned to, the thing I thought about when I wasn’t doing it, and it was the way I understood so much of the world around me. Lately, I’ve been wondering what happens when the thing that has occupied so much of our attention begins to share that attention with other interests. What happens when a writer becomes just as fascinated by philosophy as by fiction? When a book about a seventeenth-century kitchen becomes as absorbing as a novel? Or when an afternoon spent reading nonfiction feels as creatively satisfying as an afternoon spent writing?
Writing is how I learn about the world around me. It’s also been the main source of my identity for more than 20 years. Writing is familiar to me. It’s what I’ve always done and it’s what I know how to do. Over the years, I’ve learned a lot about creative writing, publication, the publishing industry, and book marketing and publicity. Sometimes, we lean back into our familiar habits because it’s what we know and don’t give it any more thought than that.
As a writer, I’ve found that challenging myself creatively is important. For years, I’ve been working toward understanding fictional characters and their worlds and then doing my best to bring their stories to life. Recently, with my studies of philosophy and history, I find that I’m working toward understanding the real world we live in. I find that fascinating because I always used world-building and writing fiction as a way to escape the real world. Now, I’m fascinated by it. I’m not sure what triggered my curiosity. Maybe it was simply the right time. I find the same enjoyment in discovering something unexpected in history and philosophy. I have the same desire to understand how things fit together. Nonfiction subjects prompt me to think in new ways.
There’s something refreshing about being a student again, especially when I’m learning on my own terms without goals or expectations. We can follow our interests without needing a degree, a credential, or a professional reason to justify our time. We can read a book because it interests us, investigate a question because it puzzles us, and spend an afternoon exploring an idea simply because we want to know more.
I’ve been interested in the idea of commonplace books for a few years now. Traditionally, commonplace books gathered quotations, observations, ideas, and passages that readers wanted to preserve. Their purpose was to collect the things that caught someone’s attention and might prove meaningful later. Here’s my experience with my first commonplace book.
I like the idea of approaching intellectual life in much the same way. I can collect ideas from history, literature, philosophy, and everyday experience without insisting that they all serve the same purpose. I can let one subject illuminate another, and I can return to an observation years later and discover that it means something different.
There’s a difference, I think, between abandoning an interest and allowing it to occupy a different place in our lives. I can love something without making it the center of every decision, and I can continue writing while acknowledging that other experiences deserve attention too. I even wonder whether our interests sometimes need room to breathe. Is it fair to expect writing novels to provide all of my intellectual and creative satisfaction? I did, for years. Lately, I’ve felt as if perhaps I was allowing my only sense of accomplishment to come through books I’ve written.
These days I find myself wondering if maybe creative life doesn’t work that way. Maybe it’s time I give writing fiction a chance to rest. Maybe I should give myself a chance to rest. After all, why have I always assumed that one interest (for me, writing) must always be at the center of my creative life?
I always wanted to live a life of the mind. That’s why I got my PhD, and it’s why I wanted to be a university professor. But now, with personal curricula and commonplace books, it isn’t necessary to be in formal education in order to live in a way that allows for intellectual curiosity. In other words, a life of the mind doesn’t have to be a career plan. It can instead be a way of life. I read something by Seneca or Epictetus or Montaigne, and I add notes to my commonplace book, and then I write about what I noticed and what I learned, as well as any connections I made. It’s not for a university assignment. It’s for me, because I want to know.
Maybe allowing ourselves these various interests makes us more attentive to our lives as a whole. We begin to notice connections we might otherwise have missed, or maybe we discover a new way to think about various subjects. I’m becoming more comfortable with the idea that writing isn’t the only place where I can indulge in my creative and my intellectual lives. I can spend the morning working on a piece of writing, maybe an essay, and the afternoon reading about an unfamiliar historical subject. These activities don’t compete with one another; instead, they’re different expressions of the same curiosity.